I have edited my makeup stash to what works well for me.

Face: Bobbi Brown Tinted Moisturizer in Light Tint
Concealer: TheBalm Concealer in Light
Blush: Illamasqua Excite
          Nars Exhibit A
          Illamasqua Nymph
Powder Highlighter: Kevyn Aucoin's The Celestial Powder in Candlelight
Brows: Anastasia Brow Pencil in Ash
Mascara: L'oreal Voluminous Mascara in Carbon
Eyeshadow Base: NYX White Eyeshadow Base
Eyeliner: Mac Coffee
              Urban Decay Zero
              Urban Decay Whiskey
Mac 15 Pan Eyeshadow Palette:
Vanilla, Quarry, All That Glitters, Naked Lunch, Patina, Era, Soba, Wedge, Kid, Omega, Satin Taupe, Brule, Shroom, Cork. For a bit of variety.
Boscia Blotting Papers
Lips: Burt's Bees Lip Wax